Sized up from 42 to 43 and here's the fit! They're perfect. However, where my finger is pointing is where it hurts when I put them on—I'm guessing this is a normal
Amazon.com | Arizona Black Oiled Leather Sandals Normal R 552111 | Slides
Arizona Oiled Leather | shop online at BIRKENSTOCK
Arizona Birko-Flor Nubuck | shop online at BIRKENSTOCK
Birkenstock - Florida Black SFB - Normal - All Sizes 42 (EU) | 11-11½ (US Women) | 9-9½ (US Men) for sale online | eBay
Birkenstock Arizona Metallic Copper Leder Weichbettung Größe 36-42 normal schmal | eBay